Review: Who Goes There?

-
Who Goes There? Who Goes There? by John W. Campbell Jr.
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Probably more of a 3-star than a 4-star but I've been feeling generous and despite its flaws I quite enjoyed the read. This is old as heck and it shows, in the sense that it does a whole lot of "explaining" the thing in question by having the characters make increasingly wild guesses. Something that I don't think authors can get away with anymore.

Anyway. The concept of the alien in the story is quite good. I have got a copy of the movie 'The Thing' but I haven't actually watched it yet. It's in my pile of things I'd like to watch eventually. Regardless, it seems to me that this simple story has inspired at least a few other ideas... I'm thinking of at least one episode of 'The X-Files' and some other movie that I saw at the cinema in my teens.

I'm glad to have read the story before seeing either of the two films directly based on it. I don't enjoy horror so much these days but the wild guesses kept my interest in the alien aspects of the story.

View all my reviews

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Ghost Spin

-
Image
Ghost Spin by Chris Moriarty My rating: 0 of 5 stars This will be the first book that I DNF in a very long time. I'm usually pretty strict about it, and I generally wont review a book if I didn't get to "The End." Therefore, this is not a review. I did enjoy books one and two, but I realised while reading this last installment that I hadn't paid enough attention to the details and that by this point I was not at all impressed enough. And this is sincerely not a fault of the books. I'm a little distracted and over-committed at the moment and I do plan to come back and give the whole trilogy a proper run. But with that said, this story wasn't grabbing me enough to push on through. I'm quitting so that I can get back to my reading plan for now. View all my reviews
Read more

Review: Weird Tales v26n04 October 1935

-
Image
Weird Tales v26n04 October 1935 by Kurtis Krimes My rating: 4 of 5 stars This review is for C.L. Moore's 'The Cold Gray God.' Northwest is on Mars again, again.... again. Which is fine but I really wanted to head back to Venus. Anyway, at least it's not the same old dusty environs, here we start with a snowy setting on "Righa, pole city of Mars." Otherwise, it's a bit of a classic start for a Northwest. He spots a beautiful woman standing out from the crowd and she asks "will you come with me?" Of course, Northwest knows what she means by this, because apparently he could tell that she was no ordinary lady of the streets, but this reader could not parse any deep meaning from the exchange. Naturally, he follows. Well, at least to half satisfy my Venusian dreams, the lady in question is "Judai of Venus [who] had been the toast of three planets a few years past." Her songs once celebrated through to the ...
Read more

Review: Linesman

-
Image
Linesman by S.K. Dunstall My rating: 3 of 5 stars For this review I'd like to invite spoilers into the comments.... if you have an idea about what the fkn "lines" are please enlighten me. Don't fear for spoilers in the review though because I couldn't spoil this story if I tried. I'm trying to write a speedy review because I'm nearly late for work (squeezed this in so I can read something else when I get home).... which reminds me. There's a quote on the cover which claims this is a fast-paced story and I don't think that's entirely true. It dragged for me. I'll admit there were some sudden changes and some events which were dealt with super briefly. For example, there was an execution which took place over the course of a single sentence. The mystical "lines" seem underdeveloped to me. They somehow represent sections of spaceships; line 1 for crew, line 5 or 6 was comms, line 10 the ship itself...
Read more